Description
The Taylor’s 1873 Comanchero Rifle, .45 Colt, 20″, Walnut Stock, Case Hardened is a modern-built, faithful reproduction of the legendary Winchester lever-action rifle. It’s a robust, reliable firearm chambered in .45 Colt, designed for practical use, competition, and hunting, blending classic aesthetics with modern manufacturing precision for immediate, dependable performance.
Key Features
- Authentic 1873 Action: Features the classic toggle-link locking system, known for its smooth, fast lever throw and solid lockup.
- Practical .45 Colt Chambering: Delivers manageable recoil with effective terminal ballistics for medium game and target shooting.
- 20″ Barrel Configuration: Offers an ideal balance between maneuverability and sight radius for quick handling in brush or on the move.
- Case Hardened Frame & Walnut Stock: Provides a classic, durable finish that resists wear, paired with a hand-fitted American walnut stock for a secure, traditional grip.
- Ready for Action: This rifle is drop-in ready for use with standard .45 Colt ammunition, requiring no gunsmithing to begin training or competition.
Specifications & Details
| Caliber | .45 Colt |
| Barrel Length | 20 inches |
| Overall Length | Approx. 39 inches |
| Weight | Approx. 7.5 lbs |
| Capacity | 10+1 Rounds |
| Finish | Case Hardened Frame, Blued Barrel |
When it comes to a defensive scenario on a rural property or a hunting trip where a fast follow-up shot is critical, the smooth lever action of the Comanchero allows for rapid, instinctive firing. The rifle’s heft, coming in around 7.5 pounds, helps manage the .45 Colt’s recoil, keeping you on target. Its 20-inch barrel provides a clear sight picture without being unwieldy in tight spaces like a vehicle cab or a wooded trail. The classic design isn’t just for show—it’s a proven system that works when you need it. This model is available at firearms-missouri.com for Missouri residents and nationwide after the required FFL transfer.
Who This Rifle Is For
This is for the shooter who values mechanical elegance and practical history. It’s for the competitor in Cowboy Action Shooting who needs a reliable, period-correct rifle that can cycle match after match. It’s for the hunter pursuing whitetail in Missouri’s hardwoods with a cartridge that has over a century of proven performance. It’s also for the homesteader who wants a definitive, straightforward tool for perimeter defense where its authoritative report and stopping power are assets. At $1609.27, it represents a serious investment in a firearm that serves as both a functional tool and a piece of American heritage.
Pros & Cons
Pros: The action is incredibly smooth and fast with practice, allowing for rapid, accurate shots. The .45 Colt cartridge, especially in modern +P loadings from brands like Buffalo Bore or Underwood, is potent for defense and hunting. The case hardening and walnut offer timeless durability and aesthetics. Its design is simple, robust, and easy to maintain in the field.
Cons: Lever actions have a slower reload process compared to a modern semi-auto. The tubular magazine capacity is limited to 10 rounds. Sourcing premium defensive or hunting ammunition in .45 Colt can be more expensive and less common than, say, .30-30 Winchester. That said, for its intended roles, these are acceptable trade-offs for many shooters.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: Can this rifle handle modern, high-pressure .45 Colt ammunition?
A: Yes, but with an important distinction. The Taylor’s 1873 is built to modern steel standards and can safely fire SAAMI-spec .45 Colt ammunition, which includes many modern defensive and hunting loads. Always consult your manual and ensure any ammunition is within SAAMI pressure specifications for the cartridge.
Q: Is this rifle suitable for Cowboy Action Shooting (CAS) competitions?
A: Absolutely. The Taylor’s 1873 Comanchero is a premier choice for CAS. Its 20″ barrel, chambering in .45 Colt, and authentic toggle-link action make it a mainstay on the firing line. Its smooth operation straight from the box gives competitors a reliable edge.
Q: What type of optics or sights can be mounted?
A: The rifle comes with traditional iron sights, which are fast and effective for the ranges it’s designed for. The top of the receiver is typically drilled and tapped, allowing for the installation of a scout-style scope mount or a tang-mounted peep sight from brands like Marble’s Arms, offering flexibility for your preferred sighting system.
Ready to handle a piece of history built for the present? Secure your Taylor’s 1873 Comanchero through our network.



Reviews
There are no reviews yet.